Juan A. Fraire

Researcher in Space Networking and Informatics

Inria CONICET Saarland University

Publications Conference paper · Mega-constellations · 2025

Anyone, Anywhere, not Everyone, Everywhere: Starlink Doesn't End the Digital Divide

Wesley Woo, Juan A. Fraire, Sylvia Ratnasamy, Scott Shenker, and Shaddi Hasan

ACM Workshop on Hot Topics in Networks (HotNets), pp. 114–122, 2025

Read on HALfreePublisher’s versionfree

ShareLinkedInXBlueskyEmail

Abstract

Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellite constellations, such as Starlink, are increasingly promoted as a solution to the digital divide in rural and underserved communities. In this paper, we take a closer look at the limits of this approach. Using the insight that capacity limitations of LEO-based access networks are driven by peak demand density, we introduce a simple analytical model that brings together real-world demand data with the physical and regulatory limits of LEO satellite networks. Applying our model to broadband demand across the United States, we find that serving the current Starlink constellation size is likely insufficient for covering all un- and underserved locations in the US and we find diminishing returns that disincentivize scaling the constellation to serve the long-tail of these un(der)served locations. We also identify that Starlink's current pricing is likely unaffordable for the majority of these locations, even with existing government subsidies. We argue that LEO constellations, while technologically impressive, are just another piece of the solution, rather than a panacea. New, innovative approaches are still required to end the digital divide.

Cite

DOI 10.1145/3772356.3772383

BibTeX
@inproceedings{DBLP:conf/hotnets/WooFRSH25,
  author    = {Wesley Woo and Juan A. Fraire and Sylvia Ratnasamy and Scott Shenker and Shaddi Hasan},
  editor    = {Alan Zaoxing Liu and Philip Brighten Godfrey and Barath Raghavan},
  title     = {Anyone, Anywhere, not Everyone, Everywhere: Starlink Doesn't End the Digital Divide},
  booktitle = {ACM Workshop on Hot Topics in Networks (HotNets)},
  pages     = {114--122},
  publisher = {{ACM}},
  year      = {2025},
  doi       = {10.1145/3772356.3772383}
}

More on mega-constellations

  1. On the Use of Mega Constellation Services in Space: Integrating LEO Platforms Into 6G Non-Terrestrial Networks Gabriel Maiolini Capez, Mauricio A. Cáceres, Roberto Armellin, Christopher P. Bridges, Juan A. Fraire, Stefan Frey, and Roberto Garello IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, 2024
    Abstract

    This paper presents a framework for integrating Low-Earth Orbit (LEO) platforms with Non-Terrestrial Networks (NTNs) in the emerging 6G communication landscape. Our work applies the Mega-Constellation Services in Space (MCSS) paradigm, leveraging LEO mega-constellations’ expansive coverage and capacity, designed initially for terrestrial devices, to serve platforms in lower LEO orbits. Results show that this approach overcomes the limitation of sporadic and time-bound satellite communication links, a challenge not fully resolved by available Ground Station Networks and Data Relay Systems. We contribute three key elements: (i) a detailed MCSS evaluation framework employing Monte Carlo simulations to assess space user links and distributions; (ii) a novel Space User Terminal (SUT) design optimized for MCSS, using different configurations and 5G New Radio Adaptive Coding and Modulation; (iii) extensive results demonstrating MCSS’s substantial improvement over existing Ground Station Networks and Data Relay Systems, motivating its role in the upcoming 6G NTNs. The space terminal, incorporating a multi-system, multi-orbit, and software-defined architecture, can handle Terabit-scale daily data volumes and minute-scale latencies. It offers a compact, power-efficient solution for properly integrating LEO platforms as space internet nodes.

  2. RF-Assisted Uncertainty Cone Reduction in Free-Space Optical Inter-Satellite Links Elena Fernández-Niño, Juan A. Fraire, Adriano Camps, and Joan Adrià Ruiz-de-Azua IEEE Open Journal of the Communications Society, 2024
    Abstract

    One of the space communications industry’s current focuses is developing high-throughput communication terminals for satellite-to-satellite communication links. Optical inter-satellite links provide high data rates, long-range, and robustness against interferences, and they do not require frequency licensing as radiofrequency communication systems. Nevertheless, as the uncertain location of the receiver is comprised in an area larger than that illuminated by the transmitting laser, the pointing accuracy is a critical element in the success of the optical link establishment and maintenance, requiring a pointing, acquisition, and tracking mechanism. The acquisition process is the most time-consuming of the pointing processes, limiting the time available to send data, especially in highly dynamic networks. This paper focuses on reducing the acquisition time by reducing the initial satellite position uncertainty. To this end, a hybrid system that combines RF and optical technologies in a single communication module is proposed. Whereas the control plane is managed via the RF link to exchange more precise global navigation data, the optical link corresponds to the data plane in which payload data is exchanged. The pointing between two satellites is simulated to analyze its behavior, considering the error of cumulative orbital propagation data and global navigation satellite system data. This work also analyzes the cumulative error produced by the propagation of the TLEs over time. Finally, the results show how a system that relies on the exchange of global navigation satellite system positioning data achieves up to 99.45% better-pointing accuracy than a system that bases positioning data on TLE propagation.

  3. Distributed On-Demand Routing for LEO Mega-Constellations: A Starlink Case Study Gregory Stock, Juan A. Fraire, and Holger Hermanns Advanced Satellite Multimedia Systems Conference and Signal Processing for Space Communications Workshop (ASMS/SPSC), 2022
    Abstract

    The design and launch of large-scale satellite networks create an imminent demand for efficient and delay-minimising routing methods. With the rising number of satellites in such constellations, pre-computing all shortest routes between all satellites and for all times becomes more and more infeasible due to space and time limitations. Even though distributed on-demand routing methods were developed for specific LEO satellite network configurations, they are not suited for increasingly popular mega-constellations based on Walker Delta formations.The contributions of this paper are twofold. First, we introduce a formal model that mathematically captures the time-evolving locations of satellites in a Walker Delta constellation and use it to establish a formula to compute the minimum number of ISL hops between two given satellites. In the second part, we present an on-demand hop-count-based routing algorithm that approximates the optimal path while achieving superior performance compared to classical shortest-path algorithms like Dijkstra.